Monday, December 23, 2013

The Hobbit: Desolation of My Childhood

Like many people who grew up loving J.R.R. Tolkien's The Hobbit, I was skeptical of the plan to split the movie into three parts: The Hobbit: An Unexpected Journey; The Hobbit: Desolation of Smaug; and The Hobbit: Bilbo Baggins and the Prisoner of Azkaban.

Making three movies out of the 1,400 page Lord of the Rings Trilogy was one thing but stretching this beloved 270-page children's story across three overlong films? Was Peter Jackson on bath salts?

Needless to say, I feel like quite a fool of a Took after just coming out of the second movie. It was great! What I had failed to understand is that the makers of The Hobbit trilogy are just giving the people more of what they want. After diligent note-taking and extrapolating for the third movie, here, in descending order of screen time, is what the people want:

  • 9 Hours - Chase scenes. Endless chase scenes
  • 8 Hours - Looney Tunes-esque action sequences
  • 7 Hours - Something, anything to keep the plot from moving along before the next movie

  • 6 Hours - Credits
  • 5 Hours - Pensive glances (usually but not necessarily involving an elf)
  • 4.5 Hours - Main characters about to die only to be saved at the last second by an arrow out of nowhere (also works if you replace 'arrow' with 'eagle')
  • 4 Hours - Orcs leering menacingly
  • 3.5 Hours - Same orcs dying by the hundreds with surprising ease
  • 3 Hours - Inter-species sexual tension
  • 2.5 Hours - Speaking in made-up languages (often combined with above)

  • 2 Hours - Orlando Bloom paying off his second mansion
  • 1.5 Hours - Characters/plot from Lord of the Rings
  • 1 Hour - Characters/plot from Peter Jackson's feverish nightmares

  • 38 Minutes - Characters/plot from The Hobbit
  • 30 Minutes - Martin Freeman as Bilbo reenacting scenes from the British version of The Office (Note: not sure if this actually happened, I nodded off during one of the chase scenes)
  • 25 Minutes - The least satisfying Stephen Fry appearance
  • 5 Minutes - "Clever" Peter Jackson cameos
  • 1 Minute - Horrifying moment of clarity upon realizing the irony of paying $15 for a ticket to the second movie of a trilogy where what little can be called a plot centres around a villain who becomes consumed by his greed for money

All and all it was a pretty good ride. Of course this doesn't count all the DVD bonus features such as hours of footage of orcs pumping iron to hone their ripped orc bods and PG-13 sex between an elf and a dwarf.

As you can imagine, I'm pretty excited to see Peter Jackson's version of The Silmarillion due out Christmas of 2016, 2017 and 2018.

Thursday, December 27, 2012

Help us, Peter Jackson, you're our only hope

I woke up this morning grasping and screaming, the echo of my nightmare still fresh. Every blink sparked an echo of that last terrifying image - Peter Jackson's face morphing into the visage of a cackling George Lucas.

I have a theory. I don't know how or why, but I believe the creator of Star Wars and the director of the Lord of the Rings trilogy are linked in some terrible, cosmic way.

In many ways they are mirror images of each other. George Lucas rose from a little-known studio film director into the most powerful independent filmmaker in the world. Peter Jackson rose from a little-known indy filmmaker into one of the most powerful and well paid studio directors in Hollywood.

George Lucas went from thin to obese...
 

while Peter Jackson went from obese to thin.



Most of all, both men were key driving forces between the two most beloved trilogies of films ever made. And now I worry they're taking their symbiotic destiny to its final, tragic conclusion.

After inspiring the dreams of a generation of children, Lucas went on to systematically destroy those dreams with a prequel trilogy so terrible, so sacrilegious, that people dare not reference them around certain people I know or, for that matter, me.

Jackson seemed to duck that fate when he chose to adapt The Hobbit, the prequel to his own beloved trilogy. It's The freaking Hobbit. It's one of the most fun and riveting children's stories ever written. It's got a wizard, dwarves, big battles, a fantastic journey, and a dragon. A dragon. How do you screw that up?

This is how you screw that up. Late in July Jackson announced The Hobbit would be split into three films rather than the planned two. So whereas the Lord of the Rings took three movies to cover over 1,400 pages of J.R.R. Tolkien's writing, The Hobbit will take three films to cover 272 pages.

And keep in mind this is Peter Jackson, who believes an angel loses its wings if he ever makes a movie under three hours long.

Here is the ultimate horror of the mysterious hex these two filmmakers have been placed under. Lucas killed Star Wars after gaining so much power no one could challenge some of his questionable decisions. And by some I mean all. All of his decisions were just awful.

I mean, just picking one at random, having Padme die of a broken heart? How did no one call him out on that? Goddammit, George Lucas.

Anyway, Jackson once again appears to be a twisted mirror image of our friend George. When a studio attempted a blatant cash grab to shoe-horn in another movie, Jackson was our only hope to stop them. Instead he took the money and went over to the dark side.

Unless this bizarre curse is broken - a sacrificial pyre of Jar Jar Binks merchandise? - I fear we are in for another three movies of pain and disappointment.

Then again, what the hell do I know? I ate a lot of stuffing before bed last night and I haven't even seen the first Hobbit movie yet. But you heard it here first if in 2014 we somehow find ourselves arguing over whether Bilbo shot first.

Tuesday, October 30, 2012

As rebellious as possible, under the circumstances


In 1775 Britain's 14 colonies were in open revolt. The following year 13 had formed their own nation, but Britain managed to suppress the uprising in the 14th colony, Nova Scotia.

Forget the over-hyped War of 1812. This was the hour that Canada came a few whiskers away from being snuffed out long before it even existed.

It's one of the most crucial moments in our history, but almost no Canadians know about it today. Governments will never celebrate the event because it's not exactly glorious. Yet more people should know this story because it gives us insight into our psyche; our weird, conflicted psyche.

In Halifax: Warden of the North, Thomas Raddall sums up the time in one stark, eye-opening paragraph (emphasis his):

Nova Scotia, the fourteenth colony, then comprised the whole of the Maritime Provinces. The Province of Quebec was almost utterly French, conquered only 16 years before and held in submission by the British garrison in Quebec citadel. There was nothing west of Montreal but a wilderness inhabited by Indians and a scatter of trappers and traders. Thus Nova Scotia was the key to all Canada; its ports commanded the approach to the St. Lawrence all the way from Cape Breton to Gaspé and it was the only English-speaking part of the whole country. Had the Nova Scotians thrown in their lot with their fellow Americans in 1776 the war must have ended with the complete disappearance of the British Flag from North America. [p73]

Leading up to the American Revolution, Halifax was in many ways an extension of New England. The census of the towns 3,000 or so residents in 1767 lists 52 Scots, 200 Acadians, 264 "Germans and other foreigners," 302 English, 853 Irish, and a whopping 1,351 "Americans," most of whom were from New England. [p66]

So when rebellion boiled over in the south, there was no surprise to see it spread up to Halifax. The colony was ruled by a small group of elites made up of the governor and his friends, as well as a few of the richer merchants. There was basically no middle class.

When the Stamp Act hit North America, requiring all publications to used taxed "stamped" paper, Canada's first newspaper was in on the outrage. The Halifax Gazette "declared the disgust of the town and province," writes Raddal.

Provincial secretary Bulkely was nominally the editor of the Gazette and demanded an explanation from Anthony Henry, the printer who actually ran the paper. Henry brushed the treasonous content off as a prank by his young New Englander apprentice Isaiah Thomas.

But soon another incendiary paragraph appeared in the Gazette. Then it printed an anti-Britain call-to-arms in the Pennsylvania Journal under the guise of reporting on the Journal. Henry finally pushed his newsman badassery to the breaking point when he cut the stamps out of the Gazette's pages in direct violation of the Stamp Act. Henry lost the Gazette printing contract, while Thomas was banished from Halifax.

Meanwhile, Haligonians burned an effigy of the local stamp master on Citadel Hill, while the man himself had to be put under armed guard. But Halifax was unique in that it had spent much of its history as a military base in the war with France. Its civilian population was helplessly outnumbered by the military presence.

Still, by fall of 1776, much of Nova Scotia was in open revolt. At the head of the Bay of Fundy a militia of Nova Scotians besieged Fort Cumberland, the only garrisoned outpost outside of Halifax in Nova Scotia. The rebels nearly succeeded, but lacked ammunition and fell to British reinforcements  Their cause was so popular the captured ringleaders were allowed to "escape" rather than face a politically incendiary execution.

A Nova Scotia delegation travelled to Machias to meet with their American cousins and plot the removal of the British Crown from all of North America. The young congress promised troops and arms, but the American army general nixed the agreement in a letter that would change the course of history:

Camp at Cambridge, Aug. 11, 1775.

Gentlemen,
     I have considered the papers you left with me yesterday. As to the expedition proposed against Nova Scotia by the inhabitants of Machias, I cannot but applaud their spirit and zeal, but I apprehend such an enterprise to be inconsistent with the principle on which the Colonies have proceeded. That province has not acceded, it is true, to the measures of the Congress, but it has not commenced hostilities against them nor are any to be apprehended. To attack it therefore is a measure of conquest rather than defence, and may be attended with very dangerous consequences. It might be easy with the force proposed to make an incursion into the province and over-awe those of the inhabitants who are inimical to our cause, but to produce any lasting effect the same force must continue. And our situation as to ammunition absolutely forbids our sending a single ounce of it out of the camp at present.

I am, Gentlemen, &c.,
George Washington

As Raddall points out, the rub is in the last line. For want of ammunition, the Nova Scotia rebellion was doomed and Canada was saved.

It's hardly a Hollywood story. Our rebellion was crushed while the rest of the rebels left us behind to create their own country. We were basically the kid who didn't get picked at gym class on Independence Day.

But glimpsed in a certain light, Canada's origin story is noble in its own way. Having a long, bloody history has been done. What country hasn't been forged in battle? Even prissy-sounding nations like Luxembourg and Malta have seen dramatic conflicts. But a nation that didn't seize its independence so much as apply for it in triplicate, now that's rare.

Personally, I like having a culture that's defined by ambivalence, introspection, politeness and mild linguistic tension I like that when CBC Radio held a contest to find the Canadian counterpart to "as American as apple pie" the winning entry was "as Canadian as possible, under the circumstances."

And I like that we're generally embarrassed about the imperialistic notes of our history, such as the expulsion of the Acadians or annexation of aboriginal lands. I guess it keeps us modest.

So cheers to Canada and I guess Australia and I dunno, maybe New Zealand. We gained our independence by virtue of no one else wanting us that badly, and that builds character. And sure enough, now all the cool countries are broke.

Tuesday, October 23, 2012

The True Story of the War of 1812


It was 200 glorious years ago this year that Canada took its first steps to becoming nation when it took up arms against the Americans in the War of 1812 for certain reasons that I imagine are very well explained on Wikipedia.

It was that battle where we defined our Canadianness, except that we were actually British at the time, but it planted the seeds of our emancipation from the Americans. Or the British, rather. Like 60 years later.

Still, I'm told by reliable sources in government that the War of 1812 was "a seminal event in the making of our country." Heritage Minister James Moore has even renamed October the "Month of Commemoration of the Heroes and Key Battles of the War of 1812," so elongate your calendars accordingly.

I've recently been reading Halifax: Warden of the North, the brisk and lively history of Nova Scotia's capital by Thomas Raddall. I couldn't wait to get to 1812 and read about our historic butt-thwomping of the Americans. Instead, I had a revelation. I now think 1812 is nothing compared to a more pivotal moment in Canada's history: The American Revolution.

First, about the 1812:

Historians debate who "started" the War of 1812 but one thing is clear - in the lead-up to the war we were a bunch of assholes.

By 1805 Admiral Mitchell of the Royal navy had come up with a novel recruiting strategy - seizing Americans on the high seas and bringing them into Halifax as seamen on the lower decks.

Raddall:

The captains of His Majesty's fleet, not content with robbing provincial merchantmen of their crews, had begun overhauling American ships and treating them in the same way. The excuse was that many seamen in American vessels were deserters from the Royal Navy. This was true, for impressed men escaped at any chance and the Americans... were able to offer high wages as well as the supposed protection of their flag. [p133]

Tensions simmered until 1807, when the HMS Leopard fired on the Chesapeake. The Chesapeake, a 38-gun, three-masted heavy frigate and one of the "original six" frigates of the United States navy, is still today famous for all the wrong reasons. Several crew were captured, a couple were convicted of mutiny and gruesomely executed.

Back in Washington, the Americans were wicked pissed. Many pushed the government to declare war on Britain while the blokes had their hands full with Napoleon. The Americans first placed an embargo on trade with Europe  - a blow aimed straight at the British army's stomach [p135].

This was actually great for Halifax (population circa 10,000), which had the lucrative role of laundering shipments ostensibly for Nova Scotia but actually destined for Europe. Then in 1811 the Americans got their revenge for the Chesapeake when the US frigate President fired on the British sloop Little Belt without warning, killing 16 men and wounding 21.

Shit was pretty much destined to be on. Sure there were grievances, but more than anything it was about American opportunity. Raddall:

But a real cause for alarm was the ancient truth that weakness invites attack. Canada looked an easy prize while Britain was heavily engaged in Europe, and all the gossip from the United States was of preparations for attack by land and sea. [p138]

...

President Madison chose his moment in June. American armies promptly marched over the border of Upper Canada and a host of Yankee privateers put out into the Atlantic. The first news of war for many a British merchant skipper was the capture of his ship and cargo on the high seas.

It was great timing. Britain had more ships than she could maintain, leaving many under-maintained, under-manned, and under-gunned. The Americans swiftly imposed their presence when the US frigate Constitution ravaged the British frigate Guerriere.

Now it was Britain's turn for revenge, and they went after the ship that had been the spark of the conflict, the Chesapeake. Raddall reports Boston pleasure boats sailing out to watch the battle as the HMS Shannon sailed into Massachusetts to face its rival. The two ships unloaded on each other and the Chesapeake was badly damaged. As the Shannon's crew drew in close to board, Chesapeake captain James Lawrence was cut down by a bullet. Dying, he uttered the famous words "Don't give up the ship!" which would long remain a motto of the American navy.

The entire battle lasted 15 minutes. The Chesapeake was brought back to Halifax as a treasure. A young Tom Haliburton, who would grow up to create the character Sam Slick, was on the waterfront and described the scene:

"The coils and folds of rope were steeped in gore as if in a slaughterhouse... Pieces of skin and pendant hair were adhering to the sides of the ship, and in one place I noticed fingers protruding as if thrust through the outer wall of the frigate; while several sailors, to whom liquor had evidently been handed through the ports by visitors in boats, were lying asleep on the bloody floor as if they had fallen in action and expired where they lay." [p142]

So there's our fix. We got our bloody battle with the Americans, our heroic victory, some token warfare in our otherwise peaceful and almost bureaucratic history.

To pause here for a moment, Raddall's book does not touch the land battles of 1812 except to say that Britain knew they were outmatched and tried to avoid them. But suffice to say the mainland theatre really did play out like a CBC-produced Can-Con feature written and directed by Paul Gross starring Gordon Pinsent and the cop guy from Corner Gas. French, English and First Nations fought side by side, defending our land against American invaders.

(You have to buy the director's cut to see where the British promise Shawnee chief Tecumseh an independent Indian state in the midwest, then later British forces run away in the Battle of the Thames leaving a badly outnumbered group of native soldiers, including Tecumseh, to be slaughtered by American troops. The Treaty of Ghent, the peace treaty that ended the war and restored lands to their original owners, neglected to ratify Tecumseh's vision. Weird.)

But Raddall does give due credit to the man who oddly enough really decided the war of 1812 - Napoleon.

As the British finally overwhelmed Napoleon's forces in Europe they could finally focus most imposing navy the world had ever seen back on North America. The rest was just follow through - a sacking of the White House here, some bombs bursting in air there, and both sides were ready to shake hands and call it a day. All that was left was to swap back conquered lands and Bob's your uncle (again, unless you were a native warrior, in which case best get used to crushing disappointment).

I know, I know. All that buildup and we only "won" because some short French guy lost? Welcome to Canada.

But if you really want close calls, there was an even more precarious moment for Canada a half-century earlier. I'll tackle this in my next blog post, which I will write hopefully sometime.

In the meantime, here's the government's official War of 1812 trailer:


And here's a more honest version:



Tuesday, September 18, 2012

Fun and Loafing Near Las Vegas

(NOTE - IN LOOKING INTO RESURRECTING MY BLOG ONCE AGAIN I FOUND THIS UNCOMPLETED BLOG POST FROM APRIL. WHILE IT MAY BE TOTALLY OUT OF DATE IN SEPTEMBER, I'VE DECIDED TO FINALLY PUBLISH IT ANYWAY WITH MINIMAL EDITING. YOLO.)

A few weeks ago I flew into Vancouver, then drove down to California with some friends to attend the Coachella music festival. As far as boring trips go, this one wasn't.

Our troupe was continually faced with the arch-nemesis of middle-class white people: inconvenience. Our car died driving through Washington State and we had to spend a night in a place called Kelso, which I highly recommend if you're a connoisseur of strip malls and/or meth. (Though there was this great diner called Stuffy's II that specialized in a dish called "stuff" and every menu item was unreasonably huge and glazed in butter and just delicious [no word on what became of Stuffy's I. Grease fire, one assumes.])

We fixed the car, headed off on an Oregon mountain pass and promptly got in a car accident. No one was hurt and after some inventive crowbar work to get the driver's door working again, we headed off on our journey. Also it rained at Coachella for the first time in 13 years.

Still, the trip was amazing and fun and, barring future dementia, totally unforgettable. I have no energy to put this into any kind of narrative, so here's my collection of random observations from Coachella and the ride there and back:


My expectations of the hipster-to-bro ratio at Coachella was way off. As soon as we drove in we were surrounded by Southern California frat/sorority guy/girls driving their parents' SUVs (I can only hope the five of us who had just driven 2,000 kilometers in a 1993 Ford Escort looked retro). Skinny jeans and horn-rimmed glasses? Rare. Ironic moustaches? Shaved. And forget about hippies, there was nary a drum circle to be found.


The complete and exhaustive list of awesome moves available to DJs:
1) Raise one arm in the air
2) Raise both arms in the air


Biggest Fashion Faux Pas as Determined and Told to Me by People Who Know About This Sort of Thing: socks and high heels.


I have seen some beautiful displays of love in my life. I've seen families that share everything with each other. I've known couples who would die for one another. My ex-roommate had a loving and committeed relationship with our Playstation 3. But I was not prepared for America's love of beer pong.



We hadn't even gotten in yet and dozens of tables were set up in the lineup. All weekend beer pong tables littered the camping grounds. Often they were crowded. Sometimes there were just guys sitting there waiting for the next challengers. Of course this means the surrounding grounds got a bit messy:




If you look Canadian enough, Americans will think you're adorable and give you free stuff like Krispy Kreme doughnuts.


Swedish House Mafia may or may not be a great house band. I honestly can't tell. They seemed to be really good at that thing where the music gets faster and higher then drops really low and bassy and everyone jumps and goes "waaaaa!" But it might also have had something to do with the stage being covered in lights and fire.


Suggested alternate name for Swedish House Mafia: Three Guys and a Laptop


Dumbest thing on sale: "vintage" Coachella t-shirts.


"Excuse me, is your car a hybrid?"


I never knew Americans had such a fixation with IDing people. Apparently if you so much as walk into a place that smells like booze you had better have two pieces of government-issued photo identification. I think I got IDed more in one week of being in America than my entire adult life in Canada. Is it some sort of make-work program?


Strangest thing heard blaring from the campground: Hootie and the Blowfish.


Best overheard argument: "No, dude. Hyenas don't hunt prey. They just don't."


Weirdest sports apparel sighting: A Raptors-era Damon Stoudamire jersey at the Dragonette show. Otherwise it was the normal collection of Dodgers, Red Sox and Yankee hats. My own Phillies ballcap elicited occasional reactions from "go Phillies!" to "Uh oh, here comes trouble."




Second-most startling Coachella moment: Jamming in a few rows away from the stage to see Radiohead amongst tens of thousands of people, only to find myself standing next to two friends from Halifax, literally the opposite end of the continent.


Most badass kid: This kid, spotted during the Childish Gambino show.


What's kind of weird about this is that Childish Gambino's lyrics are incredibly filthy:



 Most Coachella-ey overheard quote: "I draw the line at Coldplay."

Least Coachella-ey overheard quote: "No one's even tried to sell me drugs yet!"


Token slacktivism: a kissing booth where for every kiss some company put a dollar towards Africa or cancer or something.


Most "clever" plays on Coachella from myself and a bathroom wall, respectively: Brochella, Coachhellyeah.


I'll always remember the look on that girl's face when she saw the Mexican man in charge of cleaning the port-a-potties and said with a quiver of horror and revulsion "That's... his job."


Price of a cup of coffee: $5. Price of a single cupcake: $5. Price of a banana: $2.


Most startling Coachella moment: Meeting up with a friend at a diner on Sunset Boulevard the day after Coachella ended, only to learn that what I thought was a real-life rapper playing Tupac as part of a tribute, was actually a fucking hologram. Even though I was far back and drinking hard liquor out of a pop bottle, I spent several minutes completely unaware a man before me was made out of light and pixie dust. When did we get this technology? The novelty may have worn off by now, but I expect this will be the closest I'll ever come to knowing how previous generations felt when they first experienced radio, television, or Star Wars.

Tuesday, February 21, 2012

One last bit about this Hitler thing

I had hoped I'd never have to say this, but I'm about to bridge the gap between Hitler and child pornographers.

Ottawa has gone a tad loopy in recent weeks, with a few of our elected officials saying things that they probably never should have said sober. In a debate on the ending of the gun registry Conservative MP Larry Miller compared the registry and its proponents to Hitler, then took it back, then took it back that he took it back.

Shortly after, Public Safety Minister Vic Toews said opposition members who attacked the government's new electronic surveillance are standing with child pornographers. He later tip-toed away from that one after pretty much the whole country decided the bill was kind of dictatorial and creepy.

Now, I'm no rocket surgeon but I could have told Miller and Toews that quoting Hitler or likening your political opponents to child molesters is probably going to backfire. If nothing else, it opens you up to equally cheap shots in retaliation.

Speaking of...

My colleague from the Hot Room (the old parliamentary press gallery room on Parliament Hill, so named because everyone who works there is ridiculously good looking) Kaven Baker-Voakes of Empire News initially came across this uncannily germane Hitler quote. He decided it would be in poor taste to use it, but I have no such reservations. Ladies and Gentlemen, allow me to take smear politics meta with Hitler on the internet surveillance bill:

"The state must declare the child to be the most precious treasure of the people. As long as the government is perceived as working for the benefit of the children, the people will happily endure almost any curtailment of liberty and almost any deprivation," - Adolph Hitler, Mein Kampf.

Tuesday, January 24, 2012

The Chicago Sun-Times decides to stop debasing itself

Congratulations from the bottom of my ink-stained heart to the Chicago Sun-Times, which this week announced it will stop endorsing candidates during elections

Here's hoping this outbreak of common sense spreads faster than bed bugs because I suspect election endorsements are the single most foolish things newspapers do. Here I'll lay out five reasons why and then suggest a much better system.

I would love to hear some arguments from people who disagree with me on this. Clearly a lot do because over 700 publications made endorsements in the last United States election, which I find inscrutable and weird.

Why printing an election endorsement is insane:

1) It debases - Though endorsements are written by an editor or at most an editorial board, they reflect on the whole paper. The New York Times endorses Obama, The New York Post endorses McCain, etc. All the work your reporters went through to maintain their independence and impartiality? Gone, to the public eye. The institution itself is now formally in the camp of a political party, which is exactly where it ought not be.

2) It lingers - Ottawa Citizen columnist Dan Gardner continually ridicules the Globe and Mail every time the Harper government makes an inept fiscal move. And why shouldn't he? The Globe endorsed Harper for his fiscal chops in 2011. If his government fails and turns our economy into pudding, the Globe will have been wrong. The paper's reputation is now tied to the actions of a politician. Worse, criticizing the government's economic plans will now strike many readers as hypocrisy.

3) It's arrogant - As the Sun Times points out, newspaper endorsements don't have much impact. Of course they don't. Most voters have made up their minds by the time endorsements come out in the last days before an election. And even if you are undecided, who wants to be told how you should act? Especially by the profession most people rank somewhere between used car salesman and date rapist. Any first-year psych student can tell you this is not how the human brain works.

4) It's alienating (and probably bad for business) - So you're a newspaper and you endorse candidate X. Those who support him/her/it will probably nod smugly, maybe tweet it, then stop caring. But boy, are people who back candidate Y going to be pissed. They'll tear into your logic. They'll accuse you of being a conservative/liberal shill, and maybe they'll stop subscribing to a paper so clearly in the bag for that asshole candidate X. Congrats, you've lost all credibility with half your readers. Was that really worth it?

5) It's Archaic - We've supposedly evolved past the age when newspapers were openly partisan. That dark age was decades ago (or, alternately, a half-dozen time zones away in the U.K.). Most newspapers now look down their noses at the Sun chains of the world that don't even feign balance. So how can newspapers claim to be modern champions of objective scrutiny while they're still clinging to the one act that most defined the days of biased, agenda journalism? I'll say this for the Sun papers, at least they accept who they are and don't try to dress it up.

Ok, so the counter-argument to all this is that editorial writers sometimes do have intelligent, thoughtful arguments for why one candidate is the best choice. Why should they silence themselves on such a critical issue for some ideal of impartiality that most people don't buy anyway?

Here's what you do instead: be humble, be personal, and be careful.

Don't hide behind the banner of the paper. Have the writer or editorial board put their name(s) on the piece. Then, don't tell people how to vote. Instead, tell them how you will be voting and explain why as best you can. Keep in mind that every political platform benefits some people more than others. Look beyond your own situation and write persuasively about which platform will help the greatest number of people. Avoid talking points used by the parties.

Andrew Coyne of MacLeans PostMedia provided an elegant example of just this kind of thing last year.

It's that easy. And in this digital age, as an industry struggling with the issue of printing words on paper and handing them out individually, we should really jump at the easy solutions when we can.

Monday, January 23, 2012

Happy Trails

Best retirement wishes to my boss Dan Leger, who revealed today he was stepping down as director of news content for the Chronicle Herald after something like 35 years in the business. Dan will continue to write a weekly column for the paper when he's not pursuing his twin hobbies of sailing and fighting crime.

Dan was an incredibly supportive boss though he clearly was prone to some mental gaffes as he hired me and all. To mark his retirement I thought I'd relay this anecdote about him even though I wasn't there to witness it and for all I know it's apocryphal (again, Dan hired me even *after reading this blog.* What a guy.)

Once upon a time there was a Chronicle Herald columnist named Peter Duffy who wrote about Coronation Street and gas being too expensive and shit like that. As a young reporter working for the rival newspaper I was pretty sure he was the worst writer in the province, but lordy did some people ever love him. He was apparently the highest-read columnist in Nova Scotia, which I blame on grandmothers.

One time the Herald ran a front-page story with a necessary and relevant quote that contained swearing; I can't remember the details. Duffy - ever the champion of mindless political correctness - penned a column harshly criticizing his own paper for printing cuss words and not treating their audience like five-year-olds as any decent, family newspaper should.

Duffy apparently walked into work the next day with this coy, canary-chomping grin expecting his boss, Dan, to be all offended and mad. When Dan didn't say anything Duffy flat-out asked him. Dan shrugged him off by saying "Peter, I'll defend your right to print whatever insipid thing you choose."

Here we see a great example of the old adage: "If you don't agree with freedom of speech for those you suspect to be borderline mentally incompetent then you don't believe in it at all." Happy retirement, Dan. I know you'll enjoy it.

Oh, and what ever happened to Peter Duffy? Don't worry, after he retired from the paper Mayor Peter Kelly went on to hire him as his speechwriter so now the taxpayers pay his salary! What a world! And just because I can never resist a chance to repost this, here's a link to Duffy's two most infamous columns wherein he claims, in all seriousness, to have been anally raped by a ghost.


Wednesday, January 11, 2012

Top 5 Halifax Media Stories of the Year (Part 2)

Continued from Part 1.

2) Openfile opens, files


Forget print and television. You know what's not dying? The internet! A new news website opened in Halifax last year and it caused the biggest stir by a non-porn site in some time.

Openfile's approach to news can perhaps best be described as hippie-populist. It's very much about sharing, being innovative (stories are suggested by readers) and giving the people what they want. And twitter. It's edited by former Frankland cull victim Neal Ozano while recent King's grad Bethany Horne serves as news curator.

As a reporter, Openfile has been fun to watch. Halifax has an insular journalism community and several statements from Horne in particular have left other reporters in the city blinking with astonishment. She seemed to say stealing quotes and facts was ok. She chastised media for printing a mugshot of a guy, who happened to be wanted for shooting someone, because the photo was taken when the guy was 17. Even though the guy was now 18. And a judge approved the whole thing. And he was on the lam for shooting someone.

But easily taking the cake was when she claimed allNovaScotia.com is not news but merely information because people have to pay to read it. I'm not even going to touch this one other than to note a colleague's observation that by this standard Watergate wouldn't have qualified as journalism.

More notably, there have been some very public arguments when other reporters accused Openfile of getting facts wrong and relying too much on twitter and reporting from other outlets.

So yes, sales of popcorn have been skyrocketing since Openfile came to Halifax. But bizarre editorial stances and a few factual fuck-ups aside, Openfile has done some good work. They've put out interesting stories topped off by extensive coverage of the Nova Scotia Home for Colored Children.

Personally, I have my disagreements with the Openfile approach. I think beat reporting is journalism's best asset, while Openfile in many ways is the opposite model. But I've got to admit, they're filling some of that void between reporters and readers that often gets overlooked. A simple story idea like "who is the Utility and Review Board anyway?" is likely helpful to a lot of people but mostly wouldn't occur to reporters who deal with the board daily.

Openfile also pays well, which is great for the freelancers in town. The site still has that post-coital glow of startup financing (TD Bank is their founding sponsor) and I don't know if it will be viable after they've smoked the cigarette down to the butt. But as a proponent of more media I'd like to see them stick around and improve. Also, their website is pretty.

1) The Chronicle Herald vs. allNovaScotia.com: a war of words

This is easily the most personally awkward item for me as I owe both sides a debt of gratitude, but 2011 was the year the Chronicle Herald and allNovaScotia.com went to war.

It arguably started early on when allNS editor Kevin Cox retired and Herald business reporter Judy Myrden jumped over to replace him. A few months later I left allNS to take over the Herald's Ottawa bureau.

Sometime around mid-year the Herald management decided allNS had gotten too big and needed to be taken on. The paper surprisingly hired four new business reporters and started a free email newsletter called the Business Insider specifically designed to take on allNS. Meanwhile allNS hired more reporters of its own.

Then late in the year allNovaScotia cut off all Chronicle Herald employees from its site. I'm still not sure exactly what triggered that.

Also both companies had devils of a time trying to launch new websites and spent much of the year cursing the tech gods.

For readers, I believe this rivalry is one of the best things to happen to the Halifax media scene in ages. Since the Daily News shut down in February of 2008 there's been no big head-to-head showdown in the print market. Competition makes everyone better and sure enough, both sides are stepping up their game to provide better coverage.

(For a cautionary tale on monopolies and lack of competition see: Brunswick, New.)

In fact, take a look at the overall Halifax news scene between print/online - The Chronicle Herald, allNovaScotia.com, The Coast, Metro, Openfile, Frank, the Transcontinental weeklies, a few magazines - and broadcast - CTV, CBC radio/tv, Global, News 95.7.

Yes, it's far from perfect and as someone who watches the news closely I spend a lot of time griping. But I also see an impressively vibrant media scene that would be the envy of places like St. John's or (ugh) Moncton.

Look at the small cities all across Canada. Literally nowhere else do you see the mix of an independent daily newspaper, a well-staffed business news website, a weekly that takes on investigative projects, a Metro paper with strong local personalities and hell, rarest of all, a Frank Magazine.

Halifax is an interesting corner of the earth to report on (it helps that half of our politicians are insane or illiterate) and a great place to work. Here's to hoping we're not all laid off in 2012.

Monday, January 9, 2012

Top 5 Halifax Media Stories of the Year (Part 1)

People don't write about the Halifax media scene much. It's probably for the very good reason that no one cares. But 2011 was an eventful year for all of us who have secret Joseph Howe tattoos and meet at the clubhouse on Wednesdays.

Please join me and my friend Mr. Wiser's as we run down the top five storylines involving Halifax media in the past year.

5) Global's comeback... any minute now

2011 was supposed to be the year Global re-emerged from years of wandering in the wilderness. A half-decade ago Global's then-owner Canwest moved production to Alberta and cut a bunch of jobs. Ratings plummeted.

Since then, the Nova Scotia news scene has been pretty consistent. CTV dominates with a roughly 70% share of the 6 o'clock market. CBC is still well behind but has been steadily chipping away at CTV's lead and currently sits at around 27%. Global has languished at about, let me do the math quickly... 3%.

(Note: I wrote this passage early yesterday evening. A few hours later the latest edition of allNovaScotia.com came out with some updated numbers, which basically show these trends continuing.)

Then things started to change in Fall of 2010 when anchor Tarek Hagamad pulled a Kai Nagata, decided he couldn't work for corporate media anymore and quit his job on short notice. Like, really short notice. As in his boss Allan Rowe had to rush in to read the the 11:00 news.

In 2012 Global bounced back by hiring veteran CTV newsman Ron Kronstein. The station was sold to Shaw, which ended years of labour uncertainty by finalizing a long-awaited new contract with the union.

Shaw talked a big game. It spruced up the website. It was going to start a new morning show to take on CTV's breakfast television. It was going to pump money into ad campaigns claiming its reporters are 50% sexier than the competition (or at least that's what I'd do). It was going to be a contender.

But then things kind of stalled. The morning show launch was pushed to 2012, so we'll have to sit back and see if the station's multi-year comeback comes to fruition. But so far this year they've bought a new property on Gottingen Street and will move to central Halifax from godforsaken Burnside.

Also they were the first local station to invest in HD equipment so you can see your local news anchor in high definition, if you're into that sort of thing.

4) Stan Kutcher takes on the Coast and everyone's sorry

When Liberal hopeful Stan Kutcher took on the NDP's Megan Leslie for the federal seat of Halifax in the spring he highlighted his career as a child psychologist.

But that wasn't good enough for The Coast news editor Tim Bousquet, hater of children. Bousquet wrote a story pointing out Kutcher was one of the authors in the infamous Paxil 329 study. I say infamous because the study was revealed to have exaggerated the benefits and downplayed the potentially harmful effects of Paxil, a child antidepressant from GlaxoSmithKline

After the Coast story was published things started to get weird. Someone from Kutcher's camp went on Anonymous message boards and claimed Scientologists were smearing Kutcher to keep him from getting elected. Now, Scientologists have waged a war against pharmaceuticals and done shady things to silence people (to say the very least). But neither Bousquet or Alison Bass, who wrote the book on Paxil 329 called Side Effects, are members of that cult. Bousquet's crazy, but not that crazy.

It didn't matter. Ever looking for an excuse to rage, Anonymous members sprang to Kutcher's defence. The Coast claims its website was attacked, though some Anonymous members accused the weekly of crying wolf.

In the end the Coast was sunk not by Anonymous, but by a single word. Bousquet's story quoted Bass on how the study authors hid that some teens became suicidal on Paxil and had to withdraw from the study. Bass said “They essentially distorted the outcome measures, and essentially lied.” Kutcher threatened to sue.

Now lying is a tricky concept to prove legally. The Coast went to their lawyer (why the story wasn't vetted beforehand is beyond me), who told them he could defend 99% of the story, but proving the lying part... well, imagine trying to explain the complexities of medical science ethics to a jury of your peers.

Not wanting to risk it, Coast owners ended up printing a groveling apology. "The Coast retracts those statements and without reservation, apologizes to Dr. Kutcher for having published them. We recognize that Stan Kutcher is the federal Liberal candidate in Halifax and we sincerely regret having published those statements during the campaign," it read in part.

The apology came at a particularly bad time for the Coast, as it had just apologized to pollster Don Mills months earlier for a blog headline insinuating he was "push polling". Kutcher sent out a jubilant news release claiming complete vindication and spent the final days of the campaign dodging any further questions about the Paxil study.

He was then crushed on election day by Megan Leslie.

3) The collapse and decline of Frank Magazine, in that order

By a mile, no news outlet had as crazy a year as Frank Magazine. More like 15 months really as it was fall of 2010 when Frank stalwart Cliff Boutilier (a.k.a. A. Frank Grunt) left and owner John Williams sold the gossip mag to Cape Breton rich guy Parker Rudderham.

Rudderham hired several new reporters and moved out of the legendarily gross Frank bunker for a new waterfront office. Things looked bright for the 25-year-old publication. Then early in the year editor Andrew Douglas wrote a column from the point of view of sexist boor Eddie Cornwallis, named after the controversial scalp collector who founded Halifax.

There was a tense staff meeting. One reporter was fired. Another resigned immediately after. The remaining two reporters walked out and when they returned the next day they were told they were being let go for insubordination. The entire Frank newsroom was cleared out.

(Note: At this point I should say that I know all of the ex-Frank employers personally. For that matter, I know almost everyone mentioned in this piece to some degree. Halifax is a small media circle)

Frank rebuilt with a stable of new employees. They may all be quite bright, but with so many new writers and not enough experienced hands to guide them, Frank started reading at times like a high school newspaper. There was more and more snark (and lots of naval gazing) but less actual information. And why exactly are people picking up Frank but for the dirt?

To be fair, a rocky patch was inevitable. But then there were some truly baffling editorial decisions. If you haven't read Frank in a while, picture this: it's now on glossy paper and features restaurant reviews. Not funny, sarcastic restaurant reviews. Straight-up restaurant reviews. In Frank Magazine. No word on when horoscopes will be introduced.

Frank used to be the scrappy, self-deprecating organ that took the pompous class down a notch. In contrast, a recent story gushed about owner Parker Rudderham donating a chunk of money at some event. It ended - honest - by detailing the long applause he got.

Moreover, Rudderham has been quick to bully reporters or former employees who talk about him by sending out threatening legal letters. This from the supposed defender of freedom of speech and pushing boundaries. In fact you should probably read the rest of this piece quickly as I'll likely get a cease and desist order soon.

For better or worse, Frank hadn't changed much over the past quarter century. In some ways it probably needed to. The old Frank is now gone and the question is whether the new Frank will find its niche.

Rudderham apparently told staff he was willing to lose $300,000 on the venture in year one (it was profitable at the time of sale, though with a smaller staff). As a longtime reader, I honestly hope Frank is sucessful. Because if not, even rich guys only want to support money-losing ventures for so long.

Jump to part 2 here.

Thursday, November 17, 2011

NDP Numbers Don't Add Up

[Quick note off the top: this mostly abandoned blog is not at all associated with my work life and shouldn't be taken as such, but I've got no other quick outlet so I'm going to post this here for now.]

So the federal NDP released their new membership numbers today and it was widely reported that they received a solid 13% boost in membership, from 83,800 members in October to 95,000 members in November.

This bump is exaggerated for a few reasons. In reality it's probably about half that amount.

First off, the NDP previously had a separate category for 'federal' members that weren't tied to any province, which totaled just over 3,000 people.

This category was dissolved when they decided to allocate each federal member to their respective province. Fair enough. But when the chart was released today there was no mention of this. Instead it just showed the October breakdown by province and the November breakdown, and let reporters do the math. Reporters weren't told that a separate category of 3,000 members had been quietly re-allocated.

So that alone brings "new" memberships down from around 11,000 people to around 8,000, or 9%.

But there's more. The new numbers show NDP memberships doubled in Nova Scotia from 1,300 to 2,600. That's a pretty impressive leap, considering the provincial party is coming off of years of minority government that concluded in a sweeping NDP majority (memberships are shared amongst the provincial and federal parties).

When I checked on the numbers back in September I was given the 1,300 figure federally and then a number of around 2,500 provincially. After asking about the discrepancy I was told provincial staff keep closer track and the gap was likely due to the federal ranks not being updated yet.

So now we're in the midst of an NDP leadership race and all eyes are on the membership numbers because we all want to see how big the Quebec surge turns out to be (Quebec has no provincial wing so it's starting from damn near scratch). Lo and behold, there's a healthy boost across the country!

But is there really? Did Newfoundland's ranks really jump from just 200 to 1,184 last month? Did they not get the memo that the populist uprising was six months ago? Maybe it's a time zone thing. My guess is that, like Nova Scotia, the numbers hadn't been updated in a while and many months of growth were only now being factored in.

Add the Newfoundland discrepancy to Nova Scotia to the federal book cooking and your 13% growth is already close to cut in half before we even get to the big provinces. So were the numbers today really an accurate reflection of the party's growth? I report. You decide.

...Ok, I'll decide too. It's kind of bullshit. Look I get that the NDP has had a tough few months. They have an interim leader who isn't exactly setting the world on kindle, let alone fire. They no more look like a government in waiting today than they did the day after the election. They'd really like some momentum and a strong membership turnout in the midst of a leadership campaign would certainly help.

And to be fair, they didn't capital-L Lie at any point. The NDP never claimed to have 13% growth, they just put the stats out and let journalists do the math. Also when I asked questions I was given a prompt and honest response.

But this isn't quite good enough. News stories didn't report "The NDP claim to have 13% growth," they reported it as fact. There is a certain element of trust when we report what a federal party tells us is going on internally, if just because we don't see the numbers first-hand.

I think the chart released today was a breach of that trust. Maybe it was all an accident. Maybe the news organizations that reported the 13% figure have been privately corrected. But when we take a party at its word there's an expectation that 3,000 members (at least) aren't being coyly added in.

Tuesday, May 31, 2011

God is Dead: An Introduction

Even before the Darkness came, Nova Scotians viewed the weather at best as a sort of ex-con neighbour. At times it could be warm, friendly, even welcoming - but you would never turn your back on it.

Our worst suspicions were confirmed during the month of May when the sun disappeared, not to be seen for weeks. The first cracks in the public psyche were subtle. People started to listen to Elliot Smith instead of the Beatles. Normal everyday interactions became fraught with tension ("Would you like fries with that, motherfucker?")

By week two meteorologists were hunted down like dogs and publicly executed. By week three sacrificing virgins was openly contemplated. Weddings were cancelled, for who could love at a time such as this?

Last week the Halifax Stanfield International Airport was razed when citizens vacationing down south were deemed too insufferable to be allowed to return. "Maybe some day we can rebuild," Premier Darrell Dexter whispered softly as he lowered the detonator.

Occassionally the sun would peak out and citizens would run into the streets, forgeting that vitamin-D withdrawal had made their skin dangerously fragile. "My eyes!" they would scream as blinded drivers smashed their cars into storefronts. "It burns!"

The sunlight would linger just long enough for acclimatization, then inevitably disappear the next morning. The suicide rate hit 20%. "I just don't know how many of us will live to see June," said Nova Scotia's haggard and unshaven public health officer clutching a handgun at a press conference.

This is all to say that I think we can safely agree there is no god.

Now that it's June, religion has been beaten out of us, and the sun is returning, I invite you to check back here later in the week for a riviting debate/argument/blood feud between myself and my friend Dan Logan on the topic of religion.

Rather than the usual "Is there a God?" stuff we're just going to skip past that part, assume there's not, and bicker over the question of: should athiests fight for athiesm or accept and respect religious practices?

To be continued, as soon as I come back form outside.

Tuesday, April 26, 2011

Election Update: Ah, crap

[Writer's note - Usually while writing these posts I sip some whiskey for inspiration but recently I acquired a miserable bastard of a bacterial infection in my foot so today is different. Half of this post was written under the influence of a powerful and legal-but-not-technically-prescribed-to-me-per-se painkiller medication so I really can't speak to any typos and/or general weirdness.]

Dear friends,

Well, it's been over two weeks now since MC Loud's All Night Dance Party kicked off its campaign, and suffice to say it has so far been an unmitigated disaster.

First it was revealed our candidate in Oshawa was actually just a fake name made up by some punk kid. Then our candidate in Fredericton had to withdraw when it became pretty clear he was dead, with our candidate in Fundy Royal serving a life sentence for his murder.

Our guy in Brampton turned out to be a seperatist, which we probably should have asked beforehand but, you know, it was Brampton, while our candidate in Vancouver Centre fell pray to illicit cooking substances and was busted as part of a cumin smuggling ring.

I myself became mired in controversy when that damned Steve Maher stole my tape recorder and published several embarrassingly candid conversations.

I said some unforgiveable things about left-handed people and for that I whole-heartedly apologize. And anyway, in some circles "sub-human" is used as a term of endearment.

Seeking traction, we trotted out a series of promises we thought would grab headlines - annexing Greenland, changing the title of 'Prime Minister' to 'Optimus Prime Minister', naked tuesdays. But research shows that most voters are still unaware that we exist.

It hasn't been all bad. We still have the coolest party name and polls show we're tied with the Bloc in nine of ten provinces. But still, it's clear we needed a wedge issue. Well now we've got one: Democracy.

Basically, we're against it. You maybe thinking, 'but that's not a wedge position at all. Every party is kind of anti-democracy.

And that's true. Every election begins witht the parties wildly alleging that this unfortunate turn of events is the other side's fault with such unsettling vigour that you kind of feel like our 308 MPs were all sealed in an elevator and tasked with figuring out who farted.

It's all but consensus that a multi-party government that represents a majority of voters is not only less democratic than a single-party government that represents a minority, it's a heresy akin to spitting on the queen.

And thanks to our first-past-the-post-fuck-second system, only voters in swing ridings really have the power to determine government (and then, only some swing ridings. A Bloc-NDP race is important and all but has no bearing on who will be PM [or at least it never did until this election turned a wonky shade of mustachioed orange.])

But despite all of this, the other parties still go on and on praising democracy, which, frankly, is a little irresponsible. Half the world is turning itself inside out fighting for the right to vote long after us Westerners have learned that democracy is just like any shiny new toy - flat-out bitchin at first but once you've had it for a while you get bored with it and eventually don't even want to bother.

We know that 40% or so of citizens agree with us, we just need to win them over. Admittedly, getting the anti-voting demographic to vote to reaffirm their anti-voting bias is one dilly of a pickle. But luckily we've got our Edmonton candidate Seymour Butts on the job of figuring it out.

Friday, April 8, 2011

Canadians: I'm Your Man

Can you smell it? That strange scent in the air? That's the smell of excitement. Normally excitement isn't something that can be detected by your olfactory system, but today is different.

Today all the rules are broken.

When I say "Canadian politics" what do you think of? If you're like most Canadians, you think of killing yourself. But what if there was a way to genuinely enjoy politics without having to be one of those douchebags you see on Newsworld?

Well now there's a way to damn the status quo. What do we need? One word: Metamorphosis! ("Change" was taken.)

Ladies and gentlemen, I come here today to offer you this metamorphosis.

We currently suffer the choice between a Russian-sounding guy trying to act Canadian, a Canadian-sounding guy trying to act Russian, and a bald guy trying to act like he can win.

But now you have a real option. Today I present to you the newest political party to enter the scene:

MC Loud's All-Night Dance Party

MC Loud's All Night Dance Party is brimming with new ideas, while also harkening back to the old-school days when Conservatives were conservative, Liberals were liberal and New Democrats were new.

My opponents, when they're not too busy littering or torturing cats, will tell you that that there are only two choices in this election. But we here at MC Loud's All-Night Dance Party think you'll spit on anyone who tells you that after you get a load of our platform.

On National Unity

We believe that Quebec should have the power to decide its own destiny and form a distinct country if its people so choose. That said, Canada also has a right to maintain its cool province to uncool province ratio.

If elected, we will reform the constitution so that in the event of separation Quebec will have to take one of the lame provinces, like New Brunswick, with it. MC Loud's All-Night Dance Party realizes that while this may seem kind of tempting, it is on the whole undesirable. Thus we will undertake a series of unity-building exercises. Birch trees will be bulldozed and replaced with maples. Molson Canadian will be forced to taste better or change its name.

On Debates

Green Party Leader Elizabeth May must have been popular in high school as she sure is bad at being unpopular. There's nothing more pathetic than begging others to pay attention to you, so we here at MC Loud's All-Night Dance Party have rejected taking part in any leaders debate even before receiving an offer. We've got plans that day.

That said, I'd like to formally challenge my opponents to a leaders knife fight at their earliest convenience.

On the Environment

Remember the environment? Remember, like, one election ago when it was actually a big deal? Well we plan to bring it back to the forefront. Now, the last guy who did this got massacred on election day so we can't go too crazy here, but suffice to say we pledge to do something. Something that will make the environment better. It will likely involve carbon.

And while our slate of candidates may not exactly be full of doctors or scientists or people who can read, I think even our opponents would have to admit it's not going to take much to lead on this issue.

On Profiling People and then Banning Them From Your Rallies

We promise to always do the decent thing and friend you on Facebook before we creep your profile and add you to our database of enemies.

Stay tuned, voters. We'll continue to roll out our platform as we come up with it over the coming days. In the meantime, remember to vote MC Loud's All-Night Dance Party - for metamorphosis we can believe in.

Monday, February 7, 2011

Fear and Loathing in Hants County

As a rival reporter to Halifax's Chronicle Herald, I've long had a Sharks/Jets-style rivalry with the paper, complete with stabbings and finger snaps.

But I couldn't help but feel sympathy for the Herald after they released their discreetly-titled video and print feature Nova Scotia Burning!!! (exclamation marks inferred by them but added by me).

Despite exclusive interviews and top level production value around a national story, reaction was overwhelmingly negative. Pushed onto the defensive, the Herald began a spirited defence of the importance of the feature.

I decided to write a thoughtful analysis of the situation to illuminate the difficulties in reporting on racial issues. Then I changed my mind and decided to write a one-act play instead. I hereby present to you - The People vs. The Chronicle Herald; Requiem.

Scene: The Chronicle Herald and Joe Public meet in some sort of dramatic setting.

Chronicle Herald: Hey, what's wrong with you? Why won't you watch my new feature, Nova Scotia Burning?

Joe Public: Well I already followed the whole thing when the story was actually happening. I'm kind of sick of hearing about it.

CH: Spoken like a true racist! Don't you realize that prejudice thrives in silence and procreates in apathy? If we don't shed light on this important issue then it'll just breed more hatred.

JP: But, the story was covered to death. Everyone reported on it. Everyone!

CH: Well, our coverage proves that racism still exists in Nova Scotia.

JP: Yeah, but everyone knows there's still racism. Everyone! Even the racists!

CH: Yes, but Nova Scotia Burning shows how racism permeates every seam of our society.

JP: Really? Because it seems like a very specific, personal feud between relatives? Where's the universality in that?

CH: Look, you pansy, hide from it all you want but we're bringing you a big blast of truth. People in this province have to live with racism every day.

JP: So why not do a feature on that?

CH: ...come again?

JP: If you're going to do a big tell-all on a major story, then fine. If you're going to do an in-depth examination of large-scale race relations, then fine. But don't do one and then claim you're doing the other.

CH: Look, we're the newspaper of record. With great circulation comes great responsibility, and it's incumbent on us to delve into the tough issues. We're not going to just give you that shallow, ambulance-chasing daily hackery. We stand back and provide a mature appreciation of nuanced real world issues.

JP: I see. And what's it called again?

CH: Nova Scotia Burning.

JP: Ah, right.

CH: And be sure to stay tuned for our next racism exposés: Schindler's Bluenose...

JP: Oh sweet Jesus.

CH: The Green Kilometre...

JP: This is embarrassing.

CH: To Disproportionately Pull Over a Mocking Bird...

JP: Please stop.

CH: Africville History X...


JP: Look, I'm tired of being talked down to and told I need to learn every detail of a stupid action by a couple of hicks in order to confront racism. I'm tired of being accused of burying my head in the sand or told I "fear stirring up old resentments" when I say I'm not interested. I'm sick of hearing about the goddamn cross burning. I don't care if you try to dress it up with a reference to The Believer. I'm just sick of it.

CH: Was that the one with Ryan Gosling?

JP: Yeah, it's really good.

CH: You know, I saw that on Showcase a while back. That is an underrated movie.

JP: A great performance.

CH: Oh, absolutely stellar.

JP: So, if it's all cool with you, I'm just going to go on living my life exactly the same as before I saw your feature.

CH: YOU CAN'T HANDLE THE TRUTH!

JP: See, that's exactly what I'm talking about.

CH: Sorry. That's just a line from our upcoming news feature, A Few Good Maritimers.

Paul Haggis: Excuse me is this the Chronicle Herald? I saw your piece and I'd like to drop off a resume.

Fin.

OK, so it's easy to make fun of the Herald for their occassional tendency to slip into pompousness, but they do deserve some praise.

While the headline was over the top, the stories themselves were done in a thorough, respectful tone. They provided an exclusive look at the Rehbergs, and it really did look professional. (Director Jayson Taylor jumped to the Herald last fall from the Globe and Mail, where he was highly acclaimed. Dude's won one or two Emmy Awards. He clearly knows his stuff.) The people involved in the feature have every right to be proud of their work.

The reason some of us rolled our eyes is the context. There are a lot of issues that deserved as much or more attention but didn't get it. It was hard not to be frustrated that this is where the Herald chose to flex its muscle and splurge on a level of detail and production value normally reserved for whenever Sidney Crosby burps.

But while it seems egregious as a stand-alone, as part of a bigger series of in-depth think pieces it could fit in nicely. That's exactly what the Herald has promised it is going to do.

So, fellow scoffers, I propose we give the Herald the benefit of the doubt. Nova Scotia Burning may go down as a leap into enterprise reporting and the first step in the Herald upping its game.

And if not, at least we'll have the inevitable motion picture adaption directed by Paul Haggis.

Wednesday, January 19, 2011

The oval of my ire

Following up my last blog post where I defended cynicism and criticized innovation, it seems I'm now going to attack a beloved project that has united all of Halifax, and argue for more bureaucratic red tape.

Sigh. Let's get this over with.

The way thing's are going, Halifax will have a new permanent skating oval on the central Common. People are going crazy for it, and our politicians aren't exactly bandwagon-adverse, so it's got good odds.

And there are some great reasons to have an oval (for a summary, see this Tim Bousquet editorial in The Coast.) But some huge questions haven't been resolved.

Say you're tripping out one weekend and decide to build a big fort in your living room. It turns out you love the fort and want to keep it. But alas, it means you can't really have guests over and it's impossible to see the TV or water the fern. Once the high wore off, most rational, fort-building people would consider moving it to another room where it would be less disruptive.

The oval, meant to be temporary for the Canada Games and placed with no long-term considerations whatsoever, is our acid fort.

The oval debate is wholly centered around the question of whether to keep it or not. Instead we should be asking two distinct questions: 1) should we have a permanent outdoor oval, and 2) if yes, should it stay where it is now.

Now, I'm as much of a fan as ice-skate NASCAR as the next guy, so I have no problem with question 1. My problem with question 2 is that all of the great things about the present location - it's central, it's a big park, etc. - are also downsides.

That's because for the big majority of the year where we don't have cold enough weather it'll just be wased space. A fifth of our signature park is just gone.

(I should note that some people have climbed out of their drug forts to say it could just be turned into a giant inline skating rink. Are we going to invite the 1980s? Because I don't really know anyone else who inline skates. And even if they did, we'd never normally shove the baseballers, cricketers, soccerers, frisbeers and and dog-walkers to make room for something like inline skating.)

Christ, is this really who I am now? Can I not just let people be happy? Everone loves that damn ice circle. You know, I was such a nice kid. Now look at me. I'm in my mid-20s and I've got the temperament of a 77-year-old Korean war vet.

If you google image search 'oval' you get a bunch of drawings of ovals plus this rando.

OK, gotta get through this. What about putting an oval on the Wanderers Grounds, the Garrison Grounds by Citadel Hill, or potentially even behind the new Halifax Library?

They all offer that same rush - outdoors in the heart of the city - arguably without costing such prime land. And sure, there are downsides to each, and maybe the oval wouldn't fit in any of those spots. Maybe we don't go for a full-sized oval. Maybe we have a small one somewhere central, even the common, and put a long-track in Dartmouth or wherever.

The argument has become baseball vs. skating, the Common as sacred land vs. doing something fun. But maybe we could have all of these things. Maybe we can have a great oval near downtown and preserve the Common. Maybe not. Maybe it's not feasible or is too expensive.

But why the hell wouldn't we be frantically studying to answer these questions? That's just due diligence.

Imagine if the city put a huge permanent structure on the Common with no studying or consultation. Some poor bureaucrat would be publicly crucified. But that's essentially what it now appears is going to happen.

And also, seal hunt protestors need to grow up and find a real cause! And stop freaking out about someone changing Mark Twain's words, it's not like he burned all the original copies! And Natalie Portman was only ok in Black Swan!

Jesus, how did it come to this? Well, be sure to check back next week when I'll presumably be bashing world peace and giving an impassioned defence of polio.

Monday, December 13, 2010

Waiting for the Feel Good Revolution; Or, In Defence of Cynicism

Two years ago I sat in a Halifax convention room listening to Bill Clinton give an intensely eloquent and vapid speech for a few hundred doe-eyed people. It took all of my will power not to walk out.

Then I figured, screw it, I'm wasn't working and I hadn't even paid to be there, so I walked out.

I recall this because of a highly entertaining dispute recently between Tim Bousquet, news editor of Halifax's alt weekly The Coast, and (a few vocal spokespeople for) a group of young, upwardly mobile professionals called Fusion. (Full disclosure: Tim and I are both members of a highly ineffective alcoholism support group.)

Basically, Bousquet accused Fusion of being naive Pollyanas, while they shot back that Tim is a cynic who holds back progress.

Funny thing is, they're all backwards. Tim isn't a cynic, he's a hardcore idealist. The Fusion headliners are, if not cynics, playing into inaction.

Tim takes a dim view of the world's prospects - skyrocketing oil prices, looming environmental catastrophe, crippling financial debt, Oprah, etc. He calls for basically overthrowing the system to avert disaster. (Full disclosure: Tim and I co-founded a barbershop quartet in Skokie, Illinois, but it broke up acrimoniously and that son of a bitch still has my cane.)

Meanwhile Fusion's statements come out like, for example, this: "I think one of the most important things a community can do is to engage its citizens in a visioning process to determine collective priorities."

But what happens when you try to take the cliche seriously?

Let's try this one:

Platitude: "We need to be a net importer fo grey matter."

Reaction: "OMG, so true! Repost!"

Identifiable real world consequence: Well, I suppose reducing tuition fees to attract more students to post-secondary education. But then, at a time when we're paying those tuition decreases with borrowed money, how much is affordable? Should we be lowering tuition for rich kids who can afford it, or maybe put money into needs-based grants instead.

Also, attracting bright businesses in the information economy is a no-brainer. But how? Offering economic incentives? Will they just relocate if they get a better deal elsewhere? And again, in a time of deficit, is lowering corporate taxes going to spur enough economic activity to offset the loss in revenue?

From Clinton right on down to Vince the Slap Chop guy, motivational speakers are paid to use linguistic devices to make people feel better, while glossing over ugly truths/product defects.

They are paid, often quite well, to promote a consulting form of slacktivism. From "positivity" to changing your facebook status, the more people are made to feel good about doing nothing the less likely they are to do anything.

Many would interject here and say these motivational speeches are just the first step to rolling up our sleeves and getting to work. But look at what just happened in Halifax.

The decision to fund a multi-multi-multi-million dollar convention centre quickly became polarized. Tim flipped hard to the no-side and chain-wrote his way through a ton of CC-bashing pieces (Full disclosure: Tim and I went to Vegas this one time but I can't really talk about it.)

There were many of us on the fence who thought that Tim was reaching at times, but brought up valid concerns. We waited for the rebuttal.

But no counter-arguments had close to the factual heft of the pieces by Tim and other detractors. There was a lot of talk of the need for optimism, kick-starting the downtown, and other platitudes, but little in the way of data other than pointing to suspect business plans.

I'm not saying there wasn't a case to be made that rebutted the No side. In fact, for the purposes of this piece I'm not even saying the convention centre is a bad idea.

I'm saying that I didn't see anyone wade into the numbers and made that detailed defence. Even with hundreds of millions of dollars on the line, so many people were willing to support a project unwaveringly because they viewed it as being on the side of progress and optimism.

That's not a progressive mindset, it's a blind spot. And there are plenty of hucksters out there willing to exploit it with their synergistic, next-gen, game-changing, paradigm-shifting, 2.0 crap of the week.

The feel good revolution isn't a means, it's an end. It is an industry that self perpetuates - more talk, more soul searching, more self-affirmation. We get stuck in a holding pattern, waiting for Godot to show up with his magic answers while real world problems flow on unabated.

I guarantee you the people who set up a fraudulent financial system to make themselves rich didn't do it by debating grand ideals, they did it by manipulating cold, hard details. How are we supposed to fight that if our heads are in the clouds?

So here's my five-part appeal to the bright-side-of-life crowd:

- I know that you have good intententions, that you care, and that you genuinely want to affect positive change. And I know that cantankerous old bastards like Tim Bousquet can be insufferable. (Full disclosure: Tim has very soft hands.)

I'm not saying be like him. It's healthy to have a mix of Debbie Downers and Umberto Uppers. Optimism has its place. But-

- At some point you've got to research and advocate for real policy positions. And they're not going to be innovative or collaborative or dynamic, they're going to be old-fashioned, divisive and slow.

I'm not talking about "It'll take hard work," I'm talking about situations like Afghanistan, where our choices are stay and people die, or leave and people die. It's incumbent on us to decide the best of terrible options.

- Changing the world shouldn't just make you feel giddy or happy. It should charge you with a sense of purpose and self-sacrafice. The last part is important because even simple concepts like "going green" will require making changes that will not be easy, cheap, or fun.

- Draw the line between pessimism and defeatism. Things do go badly. We need pessimism to prepare for those scenarios. Don't assume that looking on the bright side is more valuable, or productive, or true than expecting the worst. That way lies delusion.

- Finally, be critical. There's no going back - people will be trying to spin us in many directions for the rest of our lives. We need skepticism to see through it. Use the journalism trick of the better something sounds, the closer you look at it.

I argue with Tim all the time over his ideas. I think some of his grand ideas for social change are over-simplified and out of reach. I argue for a more moderate approach because I think revolutions are too easily hijacked. So maybe I'm a cynic.

But, to steal some lines from my friend Laura Penny: Cynicism is good. Cynicism leads to being pissed off, being pissed off leads to taking action and taking action leads to social change.

I'll leave you with an inspirational quote.

"Thought = creation. If these thoughts are attached to powerful emotions (good or bad) that speeds the creation," - The Secret.

When you look at that and immediately see bullshit, you're on your way.

(Full disclosure: I am a member of secret cabal of Freemasons that run both the financial sector and the entertainment industry, and have a significant financial investment in keeping the working man down.)

Monday, November 29, 2010

Accidental Genius: George Lucas

You didn't see many headlines this week saying "Irvin Kershner, director of Robocop 2, died last weekend at 87."

Many of the obituaries of Kershner, who died Saturday, contain decidedly faint praise. The first one I saw called him a "journeyman director."

But the thing no one can take away from him is that he directed The Empire Strikes Back. That may make him the cinematic version of a one hit wonder, but if your one hit is the equivalent of the combined oeuvre of the Beatles, it's not so bad.

When I started this blog with my friend Mike way back when, we thought up some recurring themes. One of them was going to be called Accidental Genius, about people whose blunders inadvertently spark sublime results. I only ever got around to writing one installment, but Irvin, this one's for you.


George Lucas is an awful, terrible filmmaker. For an excellent recapping of why, check out this weird, twisted 70 minute review of Star Wars Episode 1.

(For those who haven't seen it, I realize how absurd that sounds. I, too, once thought I had far better things to do with my time. And like you, I was wrong. All I can say is give it a chance - it is insightful and well worth the commitment for anyone who appreciates movies.)

Yes, Lucas invented Star Wars. But his early scripts are embarrassingly bad. It took the collaberation of a lot of talented people to get the movie to its final form. Lucas did have a fertile mind to contribute. He also had a knack for special effects and a ton of ambition. And he had greed, and that, ultimately, is what saved Star Wars.

After the first movie became a hit Lucas, consumed by a thirst for power that is in no way ironic considering the content of his films, ceded the director's chair because he needed to dedicate more of his energy to fighting the studios for control.

In the early days his railing against the film establishment lead to greatness. After feuding with Director's Guild of America over the trilogy's famous opening title sequence, Lucas left the guild. It's rumoured he had wanted his friend Stephen Spielberg to direct Empire, but this fell apart after the guild dispute.

Pause for a minute and think about a Spielberg-helmed Empire. Picture Yoda training Luke from the basket of a flying bicycle. Picture Qui-Gon Jinn coming in and crying "This lightsaber! This lightsaber could have saved five more gungans." Picture Tom Hanks somehow being involved.

The horror.

Instead Lucas went with the unconventional choice of Kershner, who excelled at character development, to handle the nitty-gritty directing business.

Because he was busy fighting for merchandising rights, Lucas didn't have time to huff around the set saying "The line is I love you too, Harrison, not I know." Because he was busy setting up sub-companies for every aspect of the production, he was too busy to work a big explosion into the ending.

I submit to you that it was George Lucas's terrible vices that saved us from his even more debilitating faults.

Of course years later he would take back custody of the child that was conceived by him but raised by others, and turn it into an insufferable emo kid. With no studio to rail against, no one to challenge his megalomania, Lucas had the complete control he needed to systematically destroy everything people loved about Star Wars and in turn tarnish the childhoods of millions.

Goddamn you, George Lucas.

But we'll always have the original theatrical cuts of the original movies, where Han shoots first, Boba Fett doesn't have an embarrassing Australian accent, and Luke doesn't look off at Hayden Fucking Christensen at the end of Jedi goddamn you, George Lucas.

Anyway, let's hear it for Irvin, who helped make one of the greatest and most beloved movies of all time. The guy who didn't even want to direct a Star Wars movie, but stepped up to the plate and hit a pinch hit, five-run grand slam.

Irvin Kershner, director of The Empire Strikes Back, died last weekend at 87.